When working on macOS, the choice often comes down to two options: Apple's Magic Keyboard (the official one) or Logitech's MX Keys for Mac (the most complete third-party alternative). The two have very different strengths and weaknesses. Here is the objective comparison based on public specs and repair experience.
Verdict
The MX Keys for Mac wins on nearly every practical criterion: more comfortable typing, backlight, 5x longer battery, and most importantly repairability. The Magic Keyboard only really justifies itself for TouchID (which Logitech does not offer) and Apple purists. At 5 years, your MX Keys for Mac with a €10 replaced key will still be functional, your Magic Keyboard will most likely be waste.
FAQ
Is the MX Keys for Mac really compatible with macOS?
Yes 100%. All Mac keys (cmd, option, control, eject, F1-F12) are mapped correctly. Integration with Logi Options+ adds macOS-specific features like Flow between Mac and iPad.
Can you use TouchID with a Logitech MX Keys?
No. TouchID is hardware-locked by Apple. If TouchID is essential, the Magic Keyboard with TouchID is the only official option.
What to do if a key on my Magic Keyboard breaks?
Unfortunately, Apple does not sell individual Magic Keyboard keys. The keyboard is designed to be non-disassemblable. You either live with it or buy a whole new Magic Keyboard. This is exactly why MX Keys for Mac is a better long-term choice.